There have been many letters in magazines and
internet forums about skill in angling. There are anglers who
think that catching fish on the pole requires little skill, or
that the effort required to sit behind a pair of carp rods and
bite alarms is minimal. There are people that look down on
anglers who choose feeder fishing over float fishing and there
are those that feel if you spend enough time on a low stocked
gravel pit you can't fail to catch eventually.

Pole fishing requires more skill than some
people realise. At Marsh Farm the crucian bites can be
incredibly fickle and getting just a few details wrong
might be the difference between blanking and
bagging |
Much of this attitude stems from a lack of knowledge of
these methods as other people have said before. I think some
anglers have things completely out of perspective.
Let's look at some of the examples above.
Actually handling a pole is something that beginners almost
always struggle with. Shipping in and out without tangling a
rig takes time to learn. It's not just a case of dropping a
rig in as some non-pole anglers think. It just looks that way
when you're watching someone who knows what they're doing.
Choosing the right float, the right elastic, feeding
accurately and so on all require skill that takes time to
learn.

The reward for getting things right (click
for bigger
picture) |
Sitting behind a pair of rods on alarms is another tactic
that can look incredibly easy to the untrained eye. After all,
all they have to do is cast out, wait for a self-hooked fish
to set off the alarm and then it's just a case of reeling in.
Well there's much more to it than that.
The skill here is in making sure the rig, the bait, the
rig's location and so on is all spot on. If the rig is wrong
then, when a bite does finally come, the fish might not hook
up or come off during the fight. If the baiting tactics, or
rig location are wrong then the bite might not come at all.
The preparation that needs to go into this style of fishing is
phenomenal and in a way this is why it's fun. It can be very
satisfying to plan something in such detail and have
everything come to fruition in the form of your target fish.

”On this occasion, on a Southern stillwater,
all the skill was in finding the fish, plumbing up,
baiting and choosing the perfect rig…” (click for bigger
picture) |
Feeder fishing used to be seen as a 'chuck it and chance
it' method and there are still a few who feel this way.
Choosing the right shape and size feeder, the right
hooklength, knowing when to strike and when to leave things to
develop requires just about as much skill as most forms of
float fishing. A good feeder angler will be just as active as
a good float angler.
This thing is, whether it be Wallis casting with a
centrepin, holding back a stick float to induce bites from
wary roach, tying the ultimate pop up rig, casting a lead and
PVA bag 150 yards and so on, are all relatively minor skills
in what we need to be good anglers.

”…The result was 1 1/2 days fishing, no
liners, two bites and two bream for 19lb 12oz on a water
I'd never fished before. Given the situation I'm sure
bolt rigs and buzzers were the only way of landing those
fish” (click for bigger
picture) |
All of the above can be learned in a relatively short time.
If we were to practice six hours a day, some of these physical
skills may well take us weeks before we were competent, but
however long this might take, it's nothing in comparison with
the real skills in angling. We need to put things in
perspective.

”Sometimes being able to reach the distance
with accuracy can make all the difference. Sometimes
not!” |
Knowing how much to feed, whether to fish at 11m or 9m, up
in the water or down in the deck, pellets or boilies, stick
float or waggler are the sorts of big decisions we make every
time we fish. No matter how good an angler is there's no way
on Earth that they'll get these decisions right all the time
or that they'll know all the answers before the end of their
lifetime.

”Where's the skill here? Using a centrepin?
Holding the float back? Maybe, but the hardest thing to
master when trotting for roach is feeding” (click for
bigger picture) |
These skills require years of experience before an angler
even starts to make the right choices most of the time.
So let's not be negative about other angling methods that
differ from our favourites and celebrate the fact that no
matter how many fish we catch, we still have much to learn.
It would be boring otherwise!