Many great anglers cite confidence as being a
major factor towards success in angling. In fact almost every
angler seems to think this is true. I’d have to be stupid to
go against this theory wouldn’t I? Well just hear me out.

“Do I flavour my maggots because experience
has shown me I’ll catch more? I’m not sure but my fridge
certainly smells much
nicer!” |
It is true that many anglers gain confidence using methods
they have had success with. Likewise the more they fail with a
certain method, the more they lose confidence in that method.
That’s perfectly normal.
Anglers that claim that confidence in fishing is critical
reckon that by sticking to tactics that they are confident
with, will give them the best chance of catching a few.

“In previous sessions all my barbel had come
from this peg during a 20 minute spell. I expected the
tip to wrap around any minute. - Confidence gleaned from
experience” (click for bigger
picture) |
To me they’re getting confidence and experience mixed up.
Throughout our angling life we learn by experience – What
bait? Which rig? Where to fish? When to fish? And so on. The
more we fish, the more experience we have to draw from.
For example, imagine if we’d fished a local lake for roach
and every time we’ve tried hemp we hadn’t caught much, but
when we’d used casters we’d done well, logic would suggest
that next time we’d be better off taking casters and leaving
the hemp at home. It is true that we would be more confident
in using casters on this water, but my point is that
confidence comes as a by-product of experience.

“I got my chance as expected and the result
was a new river PB for
me!” |
I believe that confidence can sometimes affect your chances
of catching in a negative way too.
Imagine you’re in your favourite swim fishing for carp.
You’ve caught plenty from there before and you’re using your
favourite boilies that have produced for you in the past.
Great - or so you’d think. Now imagine that there are a few
carp topping on the other side of the lake. Confidence might
lead you to decide to stay where you are; after all you know
it’s a good swim – surely the fish will turn up?
Well, not always. Confidence can easily become stubbornness
and opportunities can be missed.
The way I approach my angling is use logic or probability.
I choose what I think will work best based on my experience.
It sounds pretty simple but there is more to it.

“We all use baits we have confidence in but
why are we confident in
them?” |
I like to have a dabble with different techniques or
approaches. For example, instead of turning up to my local
lake with maggots and pellets and catching a nice mixed bag as
usual I will deliberately try something else. I might try
large pieces of bread flake over liquidized bread, or paste.
Most of the time I end up catching less and can discount that
method, while sometimes I stumble on a better approach. But
the important point is that by trying many different
approaches I am acquiring more experience. The more experience
I gain the more knowledge I have to aid my decisions.

“Here is a good chub caught using tactics I’d
learned by reading other people’s articles and putting
their teachings into practice. Simple
logic!” |
I reckon the angler who has a broader range of skill and
experience will catch more consistently than the angler who
only sticks to tactics they are confident with.